FORUM PAJAK KARBON

FORUM PAJAK KARBON

FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar གིས-
Number of replies: 50

Anda dimina memberikan feedback  atau opini masing-masing dalam 50-75 kata dalam bahasa inggris. 

Opini 2 adalah mengenai yang diminta adalah tanggapan anda mengenai Pajak Karbon

*Pastikan opini yang anda berikan bebas dari kesalahan grammar (diperkenankan memakai aplikasi grammar check untuk memastikan)



In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Ni Made Dewanti Cahyani 2111031008 གིས-
Nama : Ni Made Dewanti Cahyani
NPM : 2111031008
In my opinion, a carbon tax is crucial to reducing carbon emissions and also driving a green economy, especially in Indonesia, which is one of the world's largest greenhouse gas emitters. However, the carbon tax must be implemented fairly and transparently without burdening a particular sector disproportionately. Moreover, the implementation of a carbon tax can provide funding to governments for mitigation efforts, so governments must ensure a fair and transparent approach.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Muhammad Iqbal 2151031006 གིས-
Muhammad Iqbal
2151031006
Carbon tax is an instrument to mitigate the increase in carbon or CO2 emissions in Indonesia. The Indonesian government plans to implement a carbon tax as part of efforts towards a green economy and controlling increasing greenhouse gas emissions. Some parties, such as the Indonesian Employers' Association (Apindo), argue that a carbon tax will increase the burden on companies, while other parties argue that carbon taxes have been widely implemented by other countries and have been proven to have an impact on reducing carbon emissions.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Siska Amelia 2111031028 གིས-
Nama : Siska Amelia
NPM : 2111031028

Carbon tax become necessary and effective policies for a greener future. This is because carbon taxes put a price on carbon emissions, encouraging businesses to reduce the impact of the environment they create. Carbon tax promote innovation and sustainable practices that benefit climate change and foster environmental responsibility. Carbon tax and green financing are actually working toward addressing climate change.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

RICARDO HERENDRA 2151031008 གིས-
Nama : Ricardo Herendra
NPM : 2151031008
A carbon tax is a crucial step towards mitigating climate change and promoting sustainable practices. By putting a price on carbon emissions, we create a powerful economic incentive for businesses and individuals to reduce their carbon footprint. This market-based approach encourages innovation in cleaner technologies, fosters green investments, and accelerates the transition to a low-carbon economy. Moreover, the revenue generated from carbon taxes can be reinvested in renewable energy projects and environmental initiatives, creating a positive feedback loop for sustainable development.

While the intention behind a carbon tax may be to address environmental concerns, its implementation often imposes a significant burden on businesses and consumers. Critics argue that such taxes can lead to higher costs of production, subsequently increasing prices for goods and services. This regressive impact disproportionately affects low-income individuals and small businesses, potentially exacerbating social and economic inequalities
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Clarin Nayla Zhafira 2111031014 གིས-
Nama : Clarin Nayla Zhafira
NPM : 2111031014
carbon taxation serves as a significant tool in reducing greenhouse gas emissions. While it may pose financial burdens on companies or individuals, this tax aims to drive emission reductions and could act as an incentive for environmentally friendly technological innovations. Carbon taxation should be managed wisely to avoid overly burdening the public and small businesses.
It is also essential to involve the wider community in the planning and implementation processes of these policies, fostering greater understanding and support for environmental conservation efforts.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Anzeli Hayatun Nuffus 2111031032 གིས-
Anzeli Hayatun Nuffus
2111031032

A carbon tax, as a concept, aims to reduce carbon emissions by putting a price on intensive carbonactivity. This is an effective tool.However, the success of a carbon tax depends on proper implementation and considerationpotential economic impact, especially on low-income households. Achieve a balance betweenenvironmental benefits and social justice are critical to its effectiveness. Overall, while the carbon taxis a promising solution to climate change, its implementation requires careful planning and considerationsocio-economic factors to ensure fairness and efficiency
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Muhammad Abib Nur Alim 2111031066 གིས-
Nama : Muhammad Abib Nur Alim
NPM : 2111031066

In my opinion, implementing a carbon tax is a strategic move toward environmental responsibility. By attaching a cost to carbon emissions, it compels industries and individuals to reevaluate their practices, fostering a transition to cleaner energy sources. The generated revenue can further fuel sustainable initiatives, creating a cyclical benefit for both the economy and the environment. By implementing this, it will be a big step in curbing climate change and building a more sustainable future.
In reply to Muhammad Abib Nur Alim 2111031066

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

EVI MARYANA SARI 2111031034 གིས-
Nama : Evi Maryana Sari
NPM : 2111031034

A carbon tax is a policy that taxes the carbon content of fossil fuels to reduce carbon emissions and mitigate greenhouse gas emissions. However, there are concerns about its regressive nature, which can disproportionately affect low-income households. Some countries have started implementing carbon border taxes to address emissions from imported goods. While carbon tax can have social and economic benefits, its impact on different income groups and its effectiveness in reducing emissions should be carefully evaluated.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

HEPY WIJAYANTI 2111031064 གིས-
Nama : Hepy Wijayanti
NPM : 2111031064

The concept of carbon taxes as a tool to curb combat climate change stands pivotal. The Indonesian government's plan to implement this tax showcases a commitment to environmental responsibility. However, the multifaceted impact on various economic sectors and consumers necessitates careful management. An integrated strategy, coupling incentives for green tech and public education, is essential for long-term efficacy. A comprehensive approach, merging environmental concerns with economic viability, remains imperative for successful greenhouse gas reduction strategies.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Muhamad Dimas Pangestu 2111031094 གིས-
Nama: Muhamad Dimas Pangestu
NPM: 2111031094

In my perspective, the essence of a carbon tax is indispensable in the pursuit of minimizing carbon emissions while simultaneously propelling a verdant economy, particularly in Indonesia, which boasts its position as one of the largest contributors to the world's greenhouse gas inventory. However, the introduction of a carbon tax must be executed with impartiality and clarity, ensuring it does not unfairly burden any specific sector. Furthermore, the implementation of such a tax grants governments the opportunity to secure resources dedicated to mitigatory endeavors, obliging governments to guarantee an equitable and lucid strategy.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Muhammad Alghifari Amchu 2111031026 གིས-
Name : Muhammad Alghifari Amchu
NPM : 2111031026

In my opinion, carbon taxes are an effective tool to mitigate climate change. They incentivize companies to reduce emissions, encouraging cleaner practices. However, the impact on lower-income households must be considered. To avoid disproportionate burdens, revenue from carbon taxes should fund sustainable initiatives or compensate affected groups. Implementation requires global cooperation to prevent businesses from relocating to areas with lax regulations. Overall, carbon taxes, if structured thoughtfully, can drive environmental progress while addressing economic equity.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Khothibul Umam Hassan 2111031100 གིས-
Nama: Khothibul Umam Hassan
NPM: 2111031100

Opinion on Carbon tax
In my opinion, the carbon tax is a good policy that the government made. It will cause the business entity that made a lot of carbon that can damage the environment to start to be concerned about the plant waste they made. This policy will reduce carbon emissions indirectly. However, in my opinion, the amount of tax that policy has stated is too low if we compare it to other countries. It will be perfect if the Indonesian government considers the average carbon tax in all countries as well as the living costs of Indonesia and other countries.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Griselda Ladyonna Maharany 2111031096 གིས-
Nama : Griselda Ladyonna Maharany
NPM : 2111031096

In my opinion, a carbon tax is a very creative idea for development. Two main benefits can exist. First, in terms of the initial aim of the carbon tax itself, reducing carbon dioxide emissions is an effort to reduce global warming that is currently occurring. Second, this carbon tax also increases state income, apart from the initial goal. This carbon tax could be a new source of funds for the government to earn income.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

BELLA ANGGRIANI 2111031024 གིས-
Nama : Bella Anggriani
NPM : 2111031024

In my opinion, Carbon tax offers a promising strategy to combat climate change by placing a price on carbon emissions. By taxing polluters, it incentivizes the reduction of greenhouse gases and encourages businesses to adopt cleaner practices and technologies. However, its effectiveness relies on proper implementation and policies that address potential economic impacts on industries and vulnerable communities. If executed well, carbon tax can drive the transition to a greener economy while mitigating the adverse effects of climate change.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Daffa Andra Setiawan 2151031010 གིས-
Nama : Daffa Andra Setiawan
NPM : 2151031010
A carbon tax is a tax imposed on emissions of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases resulting from human activities. The Indonesian government has proposed a carbon tax of IDR 75/kg, which has received attention from various parties. Several parties such as The PRAKARSA and the Indonesia Research Institute for Decarbonization appreciate the government's steps to implement a carbon tax because it can reduce the impact of CO2 emissions. However, several parties such as Gaikindo chose to focus on implementing PP 73/2019 which will take effect in October 2021. The imposition of a carbon tax is expected to contribute to achieving the goals of climate change mitigation and adaptation while increasing economic growth, alleviating poverty, and simultaneously preserving the environment. State revenue from carbon taxes can be used to increase development funds, invest in environmentally friendly technology, or provide support to low-income communities in the form of social programs.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Syafa Alana Diningtias 2111031070 གིས-
Nama: Syafa Alana Diningtias
NPM: 2111031070

In my opinion, Carbon Tax is a tax imposed on carbon emissions generated by business activities. As a student, I believe that Carbon Tax is an effective solution to combat climate change and protect the environment. Here are some reasons why I support Carbon Tax:
1. Protecting the environment: Carbon Tax aims to reduce greenhouse gas emissions generated by business activities, thus reducing the impact on the environment.
2. Inspiring innovation: Carbon Tax can inspire innovation in the business sector to develop environmentally friendly products and services.
Reducing subsidies for polluting 3. industries: By imposing Carbon Tax, governments can reduce subsidies for polluting industries.
4. Enhancing competitiveness: Carbon Tax can enhance the competitiveness of industries that adopt environmentally friendly practices, as they must face the cost of Carbon Tax.
In conclusion, I believe that Carbon Tax and Green Financing are essential tools for combating climate change and protecting the environment. Governments and business actors should pay more attention to these financing schemes and allocate more funds to projects that promote environmental sustainability.

Thank you.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Celvin Yusra 2111031068 གིས-
Nama: Celvin Yusra
NPM: 2111031068

In my opinion, implementing a carbon tax is very necessary, especially in Indonesia, because firstly, Indonesia is one of the largest contributors to greenhouse gas emissions in the world. Second, the implementation of a carbon tax as a form of Indonesia's commitment to implementing a green economy. Third, carbon taxes have been implemented by many other countries and have been proven to have an impact on reducing carbon emissions.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Andri Satria 2111031058 གིས-
Nama : Andri Satria
Npm : 2111031058
In my opinion, the carbon tax is a positive response from the Indonesian government, which is committed to reducing greenhouse gas emissions and mitigating extreme climate change at the national and international level. For implementation in Indonesia, starting in the electricity generation sector that uses coal as fuel, the carbon tax rate in Indonesia is also relatively low compared to other countries, so this can prevent increases in the price of goods. This carbon tax is expected to have a positive impact on the environment and also increase state revenue.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Arvela Fadila Putri 2111031030 གིས-
Nama : Arvela Fadila Putri
NPM : 2111031030
In my opinion, implementing a carbon tax in Indonesia is the right step in mitigating the climate crisis and existing greenhouse gas emissions. Companies that produce high carbon taxes must be able to balance to reduce the impact of the carbon tax itself. This is also related to the company's CSR to keep the surrounding environment healthy and support sustainable environmental programs. The implementation of the carbon tax in Indonesia proves that Indonesia really pays attention to environmental health by reducing existing greenhouse gas emissions for future generations.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Jihan Fatin Fadillah Lotte 2111031072 གིས-
Nama: Jihan Fatin Fadillah Lotte
NPM: 2111031072

Carbon taxation serves as a significant tool in reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Carbon taxation should be managed wisely to avoid overly burdening the public and small businesses.
Carbon taxation is a policy that taxes the carbon content of fossil fuels to reduce carbon emissions and mitigate greenhouse gas emissions. Furthermore, the implementation of such a tax grants governments the opportunity to secure resources dedicated to mitigatory endeavors, obliging governments to guarantee an equitable and lucid strategy.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Maiyomi Sanjaya 2111031090 གིས-
Nama : Maiyomi Sanjaya
NPM : 2111031090


Carbon tax is a levy imposed with the aim of reducing carbon dioxide emissions and other greenhouse gases. The primary objective of implementing a carbon tax is to change the behavior of economic actors, encouraging a shift towards low-carbon green economic activities. Industrial activities that produce large amounts of greenhouse gases, when accumulated in the Earth's atmosphere, can lead to global warming. Therefore, a specific policy is needed to control the amount of carbon emissions generated. Carbon tax is one of the most effective ways to reduce carbon emissions by encouraging a transition to cleaner energy sources and promoting energy efficiency.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

SUCI MAHARANI 2111031044 གིས-
Nama : Suci Maharani
NPM : 2111031044

Carbon tax needs to be implemented in Indonesia considering the importance of reducing carbon emissions and the risks of climate change. To support this, the government is imposing a carbon tax of 30,000 IDR/MtCO2 with a limited Cap and Tax system on coal-fired power plants (PLTU Batu Bara). The taxable carbon is the difference between the allowed maximum limit and the actual emissions (after deducting carbon purchases from other entities). The government aims to encourage the widespread implementation of carbon taxation to support a green living environment.

In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Nur Huliyah 2151031016 གིས-
Nama : Nur Huliyah
Npm : 2151031016
Harmonization of tax regulations
1. Carbon tax
When the carbon tax appeared, many people asked, "What is the carbon tax?" and there
were also those who protested, "Wow, the tax will be more expensive, and so on."The
carbon tax is actually very beneficial for this country. The following is the government's
commitment to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions:
1.control the increase of greenhouse gas emissions in the atmosphere that cause
temperature rise.
2.The government's commitment to reduce greenhouse gases by 29%
3. Indonesia's climate change mitigation
4. Changing the behavior of economic activity actors that potentially produce greenhouse
gas (GHG) emissions
Then the carbon tax will be implemented in stages. Carbon implementation will prioritize
the principles of fairness and affordability. The carbon tariff is set higher than the market
price of carbon. It will be implemented for the first time in the power plant sector.It can
be concluded that the carbon tax is actually good for Indonesia in terms of health, but
there are some people who disagree because of the high price of this carbon tax. So there
are not a few people who consider and object to it. However, the carbon in Indonesia is
actually less than the carbon outside the country. The price is also cheaper than outside.
But because the condition of Indonesia is still developing, it is unlikely that everyone will
be able to afford this.Before implementing this, the government had already discussed
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

SILVIANDITA ARIVIA 2151031014 གིས-
Nama: Silviandita Arivia
NPM: 2151031014
Kelas: Akuntansi Perpajakan Akt. Genap

In my opinion, the main objective of implementing a carbon tax is to influence the behavior of economic actors, prompting them to shift towards low-carbon, green economic activities. This aligns with various government initiatives aimed at achieving medium and long-term targets for reducing greenhouse gas emissions.

As a highly strategic policy in addressing climate change, the imposition of a carbon tax sends a powerful signal that fosters the development of carbon markets, technological innovation, and more efficient, low-carbon, and environmentally friendly investments. In the context of development, the government's revenue from the carbon tax can be utilized to contribute in development funds, invest in environmentally friendly technologies, or provide support to low-income communities through social programs.

The implementation of a carbon tax and the development of carbon markets are crucial milestones toward Indonesia's sustainable economy. These initiatives not only contribute to environmental conservation but also position Indonesia as a serious player in the global effort to combat climate change.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Fania Anjani Suharjo 2111031084 གིས-
Nama : Fania Anjani Suharjo
NPM : 2111031084

In my opinion, A carbon tax is effective in integrating environmental impacts into the economy, but success depends on careful government management to avoid undue burdens on vulnerable consumers and industries. Supporting it with incentives for green technology and solutions is crucial for a comprehensive strategy, driving the transition to a sustainable society. Coordination between government, industry, and society is essential. While a carbon tax encourages companies to adopt cleaner practices, balancing environmental interests with economic impacts is challenging. To be effective, it should be part of a broader strategy, incorporating public education, incentives for green technology, and policies supporting an environmentally sustainable society.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Zafira Firjuan Laiga 2111031022 གིས-
Nama : Zafira Firjuan Laiga
NPM : 2111031022
Kelas : Akuntansi Perpajakan Genap

In my opinion, Carbon tax is a policy instrument imposed on carbon dioxide emissions and other greenhouse gases, with the primary goal of reducing greenhouse gas emissions that are the main cause of climate change. This approach is considered positive by many because it has the potential to significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions and encourage a transition to more environmentally friendly technologies. A suggestion for implementing carbon tax in Indonesia is to start with sectors with high greenhouse gas emissions, such as the energy and industrial sectors, and establish a progressive carbon tax rate. With careful implementation, carbon tax can be an effective tool in reducing greenhouse gas emissions, creating a carbon market, and supporting global efforts to address climate change.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Pyara Tri Amanda 2111031060 གིས-
Nama : Pyara Tri Amanda
NPM : 2111031060
In my opinion, the carbon tax holds the potential to curtail carbon emissions, bolster state revenues, and foster societal prosperity. The generated tax revenue can be directed towards societal needs, contributing to pollution reduction. Furthermore, this taxation strategy encourages entities emitting carbon to transition toward eco-friendly practices, fostering the transformation of carbon-emitting companies into green entities reliant on renewable and environmentally friendly energy sources.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Gina Diah Ayu 2111031016 གིས-
Nama: Gina Diah Ayu
NPM: 2111031016
A carbon tax is one of the key instruments or innovations for responding to the climate change crisis. The imposition of a tax on carbon emissions can encourage companies and individuals to switch to clean energy sources. In addition to reducing pollution, the carbon tax also creates green technology innovations for economic incentives. A carbon tax can also have a long-term positive impact on the environment and the global economy.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Feni Heriza 2111031040 གིས-
Nama : Feni Heriza
NPM : 2111031040

Collecting a carbon tax can be a mitigation measure for the damage that could be caused in the future. Therefore, community participation in the form of compliance and discipline in paying vehicle tax is an important factor to be improved in order to create an even greener Indonesia. To increase alternative state revenues, a carbon tax is also implemented to finance problems arising from climate change in Indonesia from carbon emissions. All parties who produce carbon to share in the costs of preventing the consequences that can arise. 
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Devani Anas Tasya 2111031098 གིས-
Nama : Devani Anas Tasya
Npm : 2111031098

In my opinion, this carbon tax is very influential in supporting Indonesia's achievement of targets for reducing greenhouse gas emissions. However, from the company's perspective, this is a heavy burden for companies, especially since implementing a carbon tax requires infrastructure support that needs to be prepared, because this carbon tax is not just emissions that are taxed, but is a mechanism to achieve this goal. reducing exhaust emissions to zero, or what can be called net zero emissions (NZE)
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Nur Aisah 2111031086 གིས-
Nama : Nur Aisah
NPM : 2111031086

In my opinion, implementing carbon taxes proves a potent strategy in combating climate change. By assigning a cost to carbon emissions, it motivates industries to embrace cleaner methods and technologies. This financial approach not only tackles environmental issues but also funds sustainable initiatives. Despite debates over potential economic repercussions, the enduring advantages of diminished emissions and a more environmentally friendly future outweigh such reservations. Carbon taxation synchronizes financial interests with environmental accountability, encouraging a shift toward a low-carbon economy.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Putri Handayani 2111031018 གིས-
Nama : Putri Handayani
NPM : 2111031018
In my opinion, a carbon tax is an important policy instrument in tackling climate change. By imposing a tax on carbon emissions, governments can incentivize companies and individuals to reduce their carbon footprint. A carbon tax can also encourage innovation in environmentally friendly technologies, as companies will look for ways to reduce their emissions to avoid higher tax costs. In addition, revenue from carbon taxes can be used to support sustainable development projects, renewable energy, and other environmental initiatives.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

FIDIA ANGGIAFANI 2151031018 གིས-
A carbon tax is a form of environmental taxation that aims to reduce the emission of greenhouse gases by taxing carbon-based fuels. carbon taxes provide a financial incentive for businesses and individuals to reduce their carbon emissions. By putting a price on carbon, it encourages the adoption of cleaner technologies and practices. carbon taxes provide a financial incentive for businesses and individuals to reduce their carbon emissions. By putting a price on carbon, it encourages the adoption of cleaner technologies and practices.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Veni Marisa Aniza 2111031076 གིས-
In my opinion, the implementation of carbon tax in Indonesia can reduce global warming and control climat change, as well as increase government tax revenues and improve energy efficiency for consumers and businesses. Levying a carbon tax sends a strong signal that encourages the development of carbon markets, technological innovation, and more efficient investment, low carbon, and enviromentally friendly investments. The government revenues from carbon texas can be used to increase development funds, invest in environtmentally firnedly technologies or support low-income communities in the form of social programs.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Nailah Shafira 2151031024 གིས-
Nama : Nailah Shafira
NPM : 2151031024
A carbon tax is a fee imposed on the burning of carbon-based fuels (coal, oil, gas). Carbon taxes are the most efficient and effective way to reduce carbon emissions and help us avoid the worst impacts of climate change. In my opinion, carbon taxes may be the best way to reduce the use of carbon-based fuels and reduce the damage to the ozon layer.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

AYA SAKINAH AZZAHRA 2111031092 གིས-
Nama : Aya Sakinah Azzahra
NPM : 2111031092
I think the implementation of the carbon tax in Indonesia is very beneficial because it can control greenhouse gas emissions to reduce climate change and disasters in Indonesia. In addition, with the introduction of this tax, coal-fired companies (which in turn will be followed by other fields) can control the rate of non-excessive and more controlled carbon waste discharges. Thus, this can reduce the risk of environmental damage and encourage environmentally friendly technology. Although in some aspects, the application of this tax may present new challenges for companies such as increased production costs and decreased buyer interest due to increased prices.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

ECIN SAPTIA 2111031054 གིས-
Nama: Ecin Saptia
NPM: 2111031054

I think imposing a carbon tax on industries that produce carbon emissions is the right step. A carbon tax will reduce carbon emissions and encourage individuals and industries to use clean energy and environmentally friendly technologies. In addition, a carbon tax can provide social and economic benefits and is potentially a cost-effective way to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

From an economic perspective, a carbon tax can increase state revenues, which can be used by the government for various environmental protection programs, renewable energy development, forest and land rehabilitation, biodiversity protection, and food security improvement. Thus, the government's goal of reducing carbon tax can be achieved.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Raihan Ramadhanito 2151031002 གིས-
NAMA: Raihan Ramadhanito
NPM: 2151031002

Carbon tax is a tax on the use of fossil fuels that produce carbon dioxide emissions. It is a way to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and combat climate change. The Indonesian government has proposed implementing a carbon tax as part of its commitment to a green economy While some support the idea, others find it complicated and difficult to implement The effectiveness of a carbon tax depends on its design and implementation, and it should be accompanied by other policies and measures to promote clean energy and reduce emissions
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

NETA TERTINA ARATRI 2151031012 གིས-
NAMA: Neta Tertina Aratri
NPM: 2151031012

In my opinion, a carbon tax produces a lot of CO2. Therefore, the government views market mechanisms as an important condition for everyone to realize that the quality of the world's environment is starting to deteriorate. That's why there is a pollution value, the pollution pays principle needs to be introduced. That's why Indonesia introduced a carbon market.

In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Grecia Hotroha 2111031062 གིས-
Nama: Grecia Hotroha
NPM: 2111031062
In my opinion, a carbon tax is needed as a way for the government to control environmental sustainability. A carbon tax is expected to be a form of accountability for companies that produce carbon emissions so that they can better regulate their usage and create creativity for companies in creating resources or tools that are more environmentally friendly in the future.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Salsabila Murtaja Harits 2111031106 གིས-
Nama : Salsabila Murtaja Harits
NPM : 2111031106

Carbon taxes are a controversial policy tool aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions by taxing the carbon content of fossil fuels, which are the main sources of these emissions. The idea behind carbon taxes is that by making fossil fuels more expensive, people and businesses will consume less of them, reducing overall demand and, in turn, emissions. The revenue collected from carbon taxes can be used to fund climate change adaptation and mitigation efforts, creating a form of "green fiscal policy". There are several benefits to implementing carbon taxes, including reducing greenhouse gas emissions by discouraging the use of fossil fuels, funding climate change adaptation and mitigation efforts through the revenue collected from carbon taxes. Carbon taxes can be an effective policy tool for reducing greenhouse gas emissions and promoting sustainable practices.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Muhammad Habibie 2111031078 གིས-
Nama : Muhammad habibie
NPM : 2111031078

From my perspective, Carbon tax is a crucial step in driving behavioral and business changes toward more environmentally friendly practices. By imposing a cost on carbon emissions, this tax not only incentivizes pollution reduction but also encourages innovation in cleaner technologies. However, a balanced approach and attention to the social impact on those who might be affected are crucial aspects to consider in implementing a carbon tax.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Mayang Arista Widya 2151031022 གིས-
Nama; Mayang Arista Widya
NPM; 2151031022

In my opinion, implementing a carbon tax in Indonesia will help reduce carbon emissions, combat global warming, and increase tax revenue. In addition, a carbon tax will also encourage companies to invest in environmentally friendly technologies. There are also drawbacks to implementing a carbon tax, such as potential production reductions and the risk of increased selling prices.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Annisa Papuanita Hefiria 2111031006 གིས-
Nama : Annisa Papuanita Hefiria
NPM : 2111031006

In my opinion, implementing a carbon tax is very important in efforts to reduce carbon emissions and stimulate sustainable economic growth, especially in Indonesia, which is one of the main contributors to greenhouse gas emissions in the world. Nevertheless, carbon taxes must be applied fairly and transparently, avoiding excessive burdens on certain sectors without appropriate proportions. Additionally, the implementation of a carbon tax can provide governments with a source of funding for mitigation efforts, making it important for governments to ensure that the principles of fairness and transparency are carefully maintained
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Annisa Nabila Putri 2111031048 གིས-
Name: Annisa Nabila Putri
NPM: 2111031048

I think that a carbon tax is a policy that needs to be implemented in Indonesia to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. A carbon tax can have a positive impact on the environment, economy and public health. A carbon tax can encourage the use of cleaner and more economical energy, thereby reducing air pollution and saving natural resources. A carbon tax can also increase state revenue which can be used to finance sustainable development programs, such as infrastructure development, education and health. A carbon tax is a responsible and visionary step to maintain a balance between the environment and the economy.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Muhammad Tipin Natakusuma 2111031004 གིས-
Nama : Muhammad Tipin Natakusuma
NPM : 2111031004

In my opinion, A carbon tax is an instrument of internalization of environmental costs introduced to reduce carbon emissions in the atmosphere. In Indonesia, a carbon tax is one of the first steps in the roadmap towards a green economy. The implementation of the carbon tax is carried out in stages in accordance with the NDC (Nationally Determined Contributions) achievement targets and sector readiness and economic conditions. However, there are several responses and impacts of the carbon tax that are of concern, such as Impact on producers, Industrial competition, Harmony between entrepreneurs.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Adella Tiara Rossa 2111031082 གིས-
Name: Adella Tiara Rossa
NPM: 2111031082

In my opinion, socialized and normalized carbon tax are a crucial things in order to combat climate change. By assigning a monetary value to carbon emissions, this approach encourages businesses to adopt cleaner practices and invest in sustainable technologies. This not only reduces greenhouse gas emissions but also generates revenue for funding renewable energy initiatives. A well-designed and well-prepared carbon tax has the potential to strike a balance between environmental responsibility and economic sustainability, fostering a transition towards a more sustainable future.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Muhammad Rizky Rico Saputra 2151031026 གིས-
Nama : M Rizky Rico Saputra
NPM : 2151031026
The approach seems well-structured and considerate of the challenges industries might face, balancing environmental goals with economic realities. However, ongoing evaluation and potential adjustments to ensure fairness, efficiency, and effectiveness would be crucial in its successful implementation.
Overall, the initiative demonstrates a proactive stance toward environmental conservation and aligning with global efforts to combat climate change, albeit with potential economic ramifications that need monitoring and management.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Putri Adelia 2111031050 གིས-
Name: Putri Adelia
Student ID: 2111031050

I am one of the people who agrees with a carbon tax because, as long as burning fossil fuels is the cheapest form of energy, we will remain reluctant to adopt renewable energy. With a carbon tax, this will raise the price of fossil fuels and motivate the switch from fossil fuels to renewable energy because it is considered more economically beneficial to switch to non-carbon fuels and renewable energy.
In reply to Rialdi Azhar, S.E.,M.S.A.,Ak.,CA Azhar

Re: FORUM PAJAK KARBON

Sekar Sabina Larasati 2111031074 གིས-
Nama : Sekar Sabina Larasati
NPM : 2111031074

In my opinion, I agree with a carbon tax. This is based on the goal of sustainable development itself, namely reducing carbon emissions. It is hoped that the existence of a carbon tax can reduce carbon emissions, thereby reducing global warming and helping control climate change. Apart from that, the carbon tax is also expected to encourage and increase investment in projects related to the use of cleaner and more efficient energy.